AMA #7: Cold Exposure, Maximizing REM Sleep & My Next Scientific Studies
- Guest
- —
- Read time
- ~5 min
- Uploaded
- 31 May 2023
- Duration
- 0:22:21
- Views
- 138.4K
KEYPOINTS
- 01
Brief deliberate cold exposure is unlikely to give you a cold by itself
Huberman's answer to the main question is 'probably not directly,' provided sessions stay in the typical range of about 1–6 minutes (10 minutes for people who really push it) and you warm up afterwards with clothes, a sauna or a hot shower. He sees no mechanism by which the cold water itself, assuming it is clean, would raise susceptibility to an upper respiratory infection.
- 02
Cold, dry air around the session is the more plausible risk
Laboratory studies that tightly control room humidity and temperature indicate that cold, dry air increases susceptibility to viral and bacterial infection. The nose, mouth and back of the throat are the main entry points, and their mucus lining traps pathogens. Cold, dry air thins and weakens that lining, while warmer, more humid environments keep it more robust. So shivering outside in dry winter air after a plunge, especially while mouth breathing, could plausibly raise infection odds.
- 03
If you are actually sick, skip deliberate cold exposure
His direct advice: if you feel malaise or fatigue because of a cold, flu or bacterial infection, stay out of the cold. That holds even though regular cold exposure can raise immune markers. He extends the same rule to hard exercise and stressful heat. Warm or hot baths, showers or a gentle sauna are fine, but not saunas hot enough to be a deliberate stressor aimed at heat-shock proteins or heart rate adaptation.
- 04
Mild symptoms are an edge case: warm up thoroughly if you go ahead
For a slight sniffle or feeling a bit run down, his first suggestion is the old-fashioned one: take a hot shower and go to sleep. If you are determined to plunge anyway, make sure to fully rewarm afterwards with a hot shower, bath or moderate sauna, and perhaps hot tea.
- 05
Repeated cold exposure nudges immune markers upward; one session does not
Across several studies, deliberate cold exposure increases the release and production of various immune molecules and cells, mainly when it is repeated over weeks. Huberman stresses that the effects are modest: in the key study they were trends, not statistically significant changes. Nobody yet knows how those shifts translate into real resistance to a given dose of cold or flu virus, which would be very hard to test.
- 06
Adrenaline and noradrenaline are the likely link between cold and immunity
Cold water and deliberate hyperventilation both release epinephrine (adrenaline) and norepinephrine (noradrenaline) in brain and body. Short-term spikes are pro-immune and can activate immune cells and molecules. But chronically high levels, especially repeated late in the day over many days, can reduce the number and efficiency of immune cells. He suggests thinking of 'can cold make me sick?' as 'what happens when I spike adrenaline?'
- 07
Suppressing symptoms is not the same as beating the infection
In the PNAS hyperventilation study (below), participants avoided fever and nausea partly because the adrenaline surge suppressed parts of the innate immune response. They still had endotoxin in their bodies; they just were not mounting a fever, which is itself an adaptation that heats up and helps kill an infection. Huberman admits he is 'saying two things at once': the same molecules can strengthen or dampen immunity depending on dose and timing.
- 08
Rest when sick because sickness behavior is adaptive
Infection activates brain 'sickness circuits' that push you to move less, curl up, look down and slump. Huberman frames this as a design for healing: the goal when ill is to devote the body's resources to fighting infection. A little gentle walking to circulate blood is probably fine if you are not bedridden.
- 09
Nasal breathing doubles as an infection barrier
He recommends nose breathing whenever you are not exercising hard, doing martial arts or talking. Zone 2 cardio and walking are good times to keep the mouth closed. Beyond reasons covered in other episodes, the mouth is a main site of entry for infections.
EXAMPLES
- 01
'Immune System of Cold-Exposed and Cold-Adapted Humans'
Participants sat in 14 °C (57.2 °F) water, which Huberman calls very cool rather than cold, for a full hour, an intentionally extreme stimulus. A single exposure did not significantly change immune function. Three sessions a week for about 6 weeks produced trends toward higher plasma IL-6 and more T lymphocytes, T helper and T suppressor cells, and activated T and B lymphocytes.
- 02
PNAS: voluntary sympathetic activation and endotoxin
In 'Voluntary Activation of the Sympathetic Nervous System and Attenuation of the Innate Immune Response in Humans,' people were injected with E. coli endotoxin, which normally causes flu-like illness with fever, vomiting and diarrhea. Those trained in cyclic hyperventilation (Wim Hof or Tummo-style breathing: roughly 25 nose inhales and mouth exhales) beforehand avoided much of the symptomology. That happened through adrenaline-driven suppression of parts of the immune response, not a stronger one.
- 03
Typical real-world doses differ from the lab
Most people plunge in water in the high 30s to upper 40s °F for 1–10 minutes depending on conditioning, far colder but much shorter than the 1-hour, 14 °C study protocol. Huberman repeatedly warns beginners not to jump straight to 10 minutes.
- 04
Cambridge winter commute
Huberman recalls standing at a T station in Cambridge, Massachusetts in winter. Breathing cold, dry air there, after a run or even through the nose, dries the nasal passages and makes them more vulnerable. He uses it to show why the environment after a plunge matters more than the plunge.
OTHER RELEVANT
- 01
Feeling good: plunge freely, but do not stay cold too long
When healthy, it is fine to rewarm using your own metabolism and shivering. Still, don't stay really cold for more than about 10–15 minutes, or at most half an hour, after the session. Dress, get into the sun on a warm day, or take a hot shower.
- 02
Slightly run down: plunge only if you rewarm thoroughly
A hot shower, bath or non-stressful sauna afterwards, plus a hot drink, is his compromise. The safer default is simply a hot shower and an early night.
- 03
Genuinely ill: avoid all deliberate stressors
Cold, intense heat and hard exercise all spike stress hormones. Despite claims that cold 'boosts immunity,' rest and gentle movement are the better choice until symptoms resolve.
- 04
Time adrenaline-raising practices thoughtfully
Because chronic, late-day elevations of norepinephrine and epinephrine can blunt immune cell numbers and efficiency, avoid stacking frequent cold plunges or hyperventilation sessions late in the day.