273 ‒ Prostate health: common problems, cancer prevention, screening, treatment, and more
- Guest
- Ted Schaeffer
- Read time
- ~5 min
- Uploaded
- 2 Oct 2023
- Duration
- 3:46:39
- Views
- 989.7K
KEYPOINTS
- 01
Urinary symptoms are the norm with age, not the exception
Ted Schaeffer, a Northwestern urologist, says 50–60% of men over 50 have lower urinary tract symptoms, rising to 75–80% by 60, and these almost always involve the prostate. A normal prostate is about 20–30 g at 40–50 and grows with age. Size doesn't predict symptoms well: men can have severe symptoms with a 35 g gland.
- 02
Waking at night to urinate is often about fluid handling, not just the prostate
Antidiuretic hormone normally rises in the evening to cut overnight urine production. That rhythm weakens with age, and alcohol inhibits the hormone. Fluid that pools in the legs during the day (look for sock marks in the morning) returns to the circulation when you lie down. Schaeffer says changing when you drink, plus knee-high compression stockings, can often cut nighttime trips from two to one without drugs.
- 03
Medications: alpha blockers first, then 5-alpha-reductase inhibitors for large glands
Modern selective alpha blockers relax smooth muscle in the prostate to widen the urethra, without the steep blood-pressure drops of the first generation. Finasteride (5 mg) or dutasteride (0.5 mg) shrink the prostate by 20–30% over time. Their half-lives are long, so Schaeffer notes that a weekly 5 mg finasteride tablet roughly matches the 1 mg daily hair-loss dose.
- 04
HoLEP has changed surgery for large prostates
TURP, still the gold standard, scrapes out tissue in roughly 1 g chunks. Holmium laser enucleation (HoLEP) shells out the gland along its natural plane. His colleague Amy Krambeck has removed 400 g from a 450 g prostate, about the size of a big grapefruit, and can operate on glands as small as 25–30 g. He estimates only about 10 surgeons in the US work at her level.
- 05
Chronic prostatitis is often not an infection
The four-glass test cultures the first void, bladder urine, prostatic fluid and urine after massage. Bacteria found only in the prostatic fluid point to a true prostate infection. Many men instead have pelvic-floor tightness, which Schaeffer treats with transrectal myofascial release, which he says can change lives. He is wary of repeated 30–60-day antibiotic courses. In bed-bound or dementia patients, he warns that indwelling catheters drive urosepsis.
- 06
Finasteride hides PSA, and that can kill
After about five years on a 5-alpha-reductase inhibitor, PSA falls about 2.5-fold. If patients and doctors don't adjust for this, a rising PSA gets missed. A UCSD study of veterans found markedly higher prostate cancer death rates in men taking these drugs, which Schaeffer attributes to this neglect. He also takes post-finasteride syndrome (lasting sexual and neurological effects) seriously and thinks young men at hair-loss clinics aren't properly warned.
- 07
The deadliest prostate cancers may thrive without testosterone
In about 100,000 tumour gene-expression profiles (the Decipher database now has 140,000+), Schaeffer's group found luminal-like and basal-like cancers. Fewer than 10% of metastatic tumours are luminal. Basal tumours survive without androgens, which makes them most likely to spread and least hurt by androgen deprivation. That is why he is comfortable treating genuinely low testosterone in men diagnosed with or recovering from prostate cancer.
- 08
Know your PSA relative to the median for your age
Median PSA is about 0.5 at 40 and about 1.0 at 50. Being above the median signals a much higher risk over the next 20–30 years and calls for closer follow-up. PSA density (PSA divided by prostate volume) refines this: he gets concerned above about 0.1–0.12 in men under 60 and 0.15 in men over 65–70. A free PSA above 18–20% is reassuring. Screening trials showed PSA cut prostate cancer deaths by 20–25%, yet about 35,000 US men still die each year.
- 09
Use MRI to decide on a biopsy, and go through the skin
PI-RADS 3–5 lesions generally warrant a biopsy unless PSA density is very low (around 0.02). Transrectal biopsies carry about a 1–4% infection rate even with antibiotics. Transperineal biopsies go through the skin with buffered lidocaine and nearly eliminate infection. Schaeffer leads a 16-centre randomized trial comparing the two. A good biopsy takes 12 systematic cores plus targeted samples.
- 10
Gleason 6 can usually be watched; pattern 4 changes the picture
Grade 3+3=6 is the least aggressive type. In the Johns Hopkins active-surveillance cohort started in 1996, about 30–35% of men were upgraded within five years, with roughly 2–3% added per year after that, about one in five overall over 10 years. Gleason 4+3, meaning more than 50% pattern 4, behaves worse than 3+4, and 3+5 behaves like 4+4. About 95–96% of prostate cancers are diagnosed while still localized.
EXAMPLES
- 01
Prostatectomy outcomes at a high-volume centre
Schaeffer quotes a 95–96% chance that surgery succeeds against the cancer. He puts continence at about 66% at one month and 95% at three months. A 65-year-old with good erections before surgery has a 65–75% chance of recovering erections adequate for intercourse (with Cialis) within 24 months, as nerve recovery takes 24–30 months. Men who already needed Cialis before surgery do 10–20% worse.
- 02
Inherited risk
BRCA2 carriers have a lifetime prostate cancer risk of about 60–70%, enough to warrant intensive screening. A USC polygenic study of about 235,000 men found that roughly 250–260 risk variants are enriched in Black men and in men diagnosed young.
- 03
A PSA of 10 at 34
Schaeffer recalls a man from his Hopkins years who had workplace screening only to get a $250 insurance discount and was found to have a PSA of about 10 at 34, not from infection. The median age at diagnosis is 68, and a diagnosis at around 50 or younger warrants genetic testing.
- 04
Advanced disease
For high-risk or lymph-node-positive disease, surgery debulks the tumour, typically followed by radiation and 6–24 months of androgen deprivation. In newly diagnosed metastatic disease, median survival without treatment is about 2–3 years. Traditional androgen deprivation alone extends this to about 48–50 months, at a real cost to metabolic health and quality of life.
OTHER RELEVANT
- 01
Get a baseline PSA early
The NCCN guideline says every man should have a baseline PSA by 45. Schaeffer sees no reason not to test earlier. Track your PSA against the median for your age and your prostate volume: if it's below 1, retest every 2–4 years; if it's above the median, follow it more closely.
- 02
If you take finasteride or dutasteride, tell every doctor
Roughly double the PSA value (Schaeffer's figure is about 2.5×) and watch the trend, since any rise matters.
- 03
Before a biopsy, ask for MRI and a transperineal approach
These cut unnecessary biopsies and nearly eliminate infection risk.
- 04
Choose a high-volume surgeon and ask for their numbers
Ask about continence and erectile outcomes, and how much nerve-sparing their approach allows.